Full Video Transcript
Hi everyone, my name is Margaret and I am a paralegal here at Tsang and Associates.
Today I want to share a case that we worked on involving a couple who fell in love, got married, and applied for adjustment of status. However, their case had many unique aspects and was not a typical relationship, which meant they had to go through many additional steps to prove their case to USCIS.
After getting married, they came to our office and we helped them file for adjustment of status, including the I-130 and I-485.
They were eventually scheduled for an interview. During the interview, they were separated and asked standard questions about their relationship. The applicant had also been on an F-1 student visa, so USCIS asked about her school and her time in that status.
Up to that point, everything seemed standard.
However, shortly after the interview, they received two serious notices.
They received an I-130 Notice of Intent to Revoke and an I-485 Notice of Intent to Deny.
This was alarming because USCIS was questioning two major issues.
For the I-130, they questioned whether the marriage was bona fide and felt that there was not enough evidence.
For the I-485, they questioned whether the applicant had properly maintained her F-1 status.
There were several factors that USCIS considered red flags.
There was a 20-year age gap. The couple had different cultural backgrounds. The applicant worked as a caregiver and only stayed with her spouse about two days per week.
To USCIS, these details raised concerns.
To address the marriage issue, we prepared a detailed affidavit explaining their relationship, how they met, and how their relationship developed.
We also submitted an employment letter to confirm that the applicant was a caregiver, which explained why she was not always physically present in the home.
Another complication was that the petitioner’s son had reported the marriage as fraudulent to USCIS.
We addressed this by submitting a notarized statement from the son retracting his claim. He explained that over time, he came to understand the relationship and saw that it was genuine.
He also described how the applicant cared for his father as he aged and dealt with health issues.
USCIS also claimed that they had conducted an investigation and found that the applicant never lived with her spouse.
However, they did not provide details about how they reached that conclusion.
We responded by submitting affidavits from neighbors confirming that the couple lived together. We also provided further explanation about the applicant’s caregiving job and schedule.
For the I-485, USCIS questioned whether the applicant had maintained her F-1 status.
We explained that it had been a long time since she attended school and that the school had closed. We also showed that her testimony had been consistent throughout.
We argued that even if there had been a status issue, she would still qualify for adjustment of status as the spouse of a U.S. citizen.
This case involved multiple interviews, serious allegations, and strict deadlines.
It was stressful and uncertain for the couple, but they continued to move forward.
They knew their relationship was real, and we worked together to present that clearly to USCIS.
If you have a similar case or any questions, feel free to reach out.
Thank you for watching.
Caregiver Facing I-130 Marriage Fraud Accusation
When USCIS raises fraud concerns in a marriage-based case, it can quickly turn into a stressful and overwhelming process.
This was the reality for our client, a caregiver on an F-1 visa who married a U.S. citizen. What started as a standard adjustment of status case soon escalated into a serious I-130 marriage fraud accusation, along with a Notice of Intent to Deny (NOID) and a Notice of Intent to Revoke (NOIR).
From that point forward, every step required careful strategy and strong documentation.
The Legal Problem: Fraud Allegations and Status Issues
After attending their initial interview, the couple received two major notices:
- I-130 Notice of Intent to Revoke based on doubts about the bona fide marriage
- I-485 Notice of Intent to Deny questioning the applicant’s F-1 status history
USCIS raised multiple concerns, including:
- A 20-year age gap
- Different cultural backgrounds
- Living arrangements where the applicant stayed with her spouse only part-time
- An allegation from the petitioner’s son claiming the marriage was not real
- Claims from USCIS that the applicant never lived with her spouse
These factors created a strong presumption of fraud that needed to be addressed head-on.
The Challenge: A Relationship That Did Not Fit the Mold
This was not a typical marriage case.
The applicant worked as a caregiver, which required her to be physically present at her job for extended periods. As a result, the couple did not live together full-time in a traditional sense.
To USCIS, this raised red flags.
But for the couple, it was simply the reality of their situation.
They knew their relationship was real. The challenge was proving that in a way USCIS would accept.
Our Strategy: Rebuilding the Case with Evidence and Context
To respond to the I-130 marriage fraud accusation, our team focused on telling a complete and honest story supported by evidence.
We submitted:
- A detailed affidavit explaining their relationship, how they met, and how it developed
- An employment letter confirming the applicant’s role as a caregiver and explaining her schedule
- Evidence showing how their living arrangement worked in practice
We also addressed one of the most damaging pieces of evidence.
The petitioner’s son had previously reported the marriage as fraudulent.
To resolve this, we provided:
- A notarized statement from the son retracting his claim
- A detailed explanation of how his perspective changed over time
- Evidence showing the applicant’s role in caring for his father through health challenges
This helped demonstrate that the relationship was genuine and had strengthened over time.
Responding to USCIS Investigation Claims
USCIS stated that they had conducted an investigation and concluded that the applicant never lived with her spouse.
However, they did not provide specific details about this claim.
We responded by:
- Pointing out the lack of clarity in the allegation
- Submitting neighbor affidavits confirming the couple lived together
- Providing additional context about the applicant’s work schedule
This allowed us to directly address the core issue while reinforcing credibility.
Addressing the F-1 Status Concerns
For the I-485 NOID, USCIS questioned whether the applicant had properly maintained her F-1 status.
Our response included:
- Acknowledging limited documentation due to the passage of time
- Explaining that the school had since closed
- Demonstrating consistent testimony from the applicant
We also argued that even if there had been a status issue, it would not prevent adjustment of status as the spouse of a U.S. citizen.
The Emotional Journey
This case involved:
- Multiple interviews
- Serious fraud allegations
- Tight deadlines under NOID and NOIR notices
- Ongoing uncertainty
The couple faced constant stress and pressure.
But they remained consistent in one thing.
They knew their relationship was real.
And they were willing to fight for it.
Key Takeaways From This I-130 Marriage Fraud Accusation Case
- Not all relationships fit a traditional mold, and that alone does not mean fraud
- Strong documentation and clear explanations can overcome USCIS red flags
- Third-party statements, such as family members, can carry significant weight
- Even serious allegations like fraud can be addressed with the right legal strategy
Marriage-based cases can become complicated quickly, especially when USCIS raises fraud concerns. But complexity does not mean impossibility. With the right approach, even the most difficult cases can be successfully resolved. This case was approved without an RFE.
Do you have any immigration questions? We’re here to help. You can book a 1h Consultation with one of our Attorneys here.