Full Video Transcript
Hi everyone. Today’s story is about a Chinese national who wanted to come to the United States and get a green card. He’s in the auto-tech industry, working on advanced automotive systems in China.
Unlike most people filing for a National Interest Waiver (NIW), he wasn’t in the U.S. on an H-1B visa. He was applying from overseas, which made his case even more difficult—especially given the current U.S.-China dynamics and the high level of scrutiny in technology fields.
He received one of the most brutal NIW Requests for Evidence we’ve ever seen. It questioned every part of his petition, claiming that his proposed endeavor didn’t have national importance, wasn’t innovative enough, and didn’t extend beyond his employer’s benefit.
The RFE went on for pages, ending with: “If you wish to withdraw your petition, please submit your request in writing. The filing fee cannot be refunded.” That line alone can make any client lose heart.
We structured our response in three parts:
1. Substantial Merit and National Importance
We addressed the government’s questions directly, using bullet points and evidence instead of abstract arguments. We proved that his work in AI, intelligent operation systems, and autonomous safety technology has broad implications for public safety, industrial operations, and other sectors beyond just automobiles.
2. Well Positioned to Advance the Endeavor
We demonstrated his qualifications—his advanced education, hands-on experience, and strong record of innovation. He had already developed partnerships and licensing interest from major brands, showing that his expertise was recognized across industries. We included five detailed recommendation letters from top experts in his field.
3. Beneficial to the United States
We wrote a detailed legal argument explaining how his future contributions in AI and automotive innovation would strengthen U.S. industries, improve infrastructure, and enhance public safety.
Altogether, we submitted a 19-page attorney brief, 37 exhibits, and months of collaborative research showing that his proposed endeavor had broad national significance.
Ultimately, the case was approved with no additional RFE.
It was one of the hardest NIW cases we’ve ever worked on, but it shows that even when the path seems impossible, with preparation and perseverance, success is still possible.
If you have questions about your own NIW case, or if you’ve received an RFE or denial, don’t give up. Reach out to us—we’d love to help you find your best path forward.
When a Chinese auto-tech engineer came to us, he was facing one of the most discouraging situations imaginable — a brutal Request for Evidence (RFE) on his EB-2 National Interest Waiver (NIW) case.
He wasn’t even in the United States yet. Unlike many NIW applicants already contributing to the U.S. economy on H-1B visas, this client was still overseas, working on automotive artificial intelligence and automation projects in China. His dream was to continue his work in the U.S., advancing technology that would make driving safer and more efficient. But USCIS didn’t see it that way.
The Legal Challenge
The RFE language was unusually harsh. It questioned everything about his case:
Whether his research had national importance
Whether his work extended beyond his employer’s benefit
Whether his contributions were original or meaningful enough
Whether he was “well positioned” to advance his proposed endeavor
USCIS even ended the letter with a line that said, “If you wish to withdraw your petition, you may do so in writing. The filing fee cannot be refunded.”
For any applicant, that kind of language is intimidating. It can make you question whether your efforts are even worth continuing. But we saw this case as a challenge worth fighting.
Process and Solution:
Our team at Tsang & Associates decided to rebuild the case from the ground up. We structured our response into three parts corresponding to the three-prong test for NIW:
1. Substantial Merit and National Importance
Instead of abstract arguments like “AI in cars is important,” we went specific.
We explained how the client’s work in intelligent operation management, autonomous safety, and AI-assisted drivingcould be applied beyond one employer—across manufacturing, public safety, and other industries.
We used bullet points to clearly link each contribution to national priorities such as:
Infrastructure and traffic safety
Industrial automation
Public safety and emergency response
Sustainable vehicle technology
We included letters from experts in various industries to show that his work already influenced multiple fields.
2. Well Positioned to Advance the Proposed Endeavor
The RFE claimed that our client wasn’t “well positioned.” We turned that around.
We showed:
His advanced education and technical expertise, directly connected to his proposed endeavor.
His record of innovation and prior success applying AI to vehicle systems.
His professional network, including partnerships and licensing interests from global brands.
Five powerful recommendation letters from Ph.D. professors and industry leaders supporting his leadership and skill.
We combined this with EB-1A-style reasoning to elevate the argument beyond minimum requirements.
3. On Balance, Beneficial to the United States
For this prong, we demonstrated that granting his NIW would benefit U.S. interests more than denying it.
Our response detailed how his research could contribute to:
Autonomous driving safety systems
AI manufacturing processes
Healthcare and infrastructure improvements
Public transportation efficiency
The final attorney brief was 19 pages long, supported by 37 exhibits, including over 20 industry reports and detailed research showing how his work intersected with multiple U.S. sectors.
The Outcome
After months of preparation and collaboration, the case was approved with no further RFE.
The decision proved that even in a high-scrutiny field like automotive technology—especially involving China—meticulous evidence and strategic storytelling can overcome bias and skepticism.
Why This Case Matters
This case shows that success in an EB-2 NIW doesn’t depend on being in the U.S. or having corporate sponsorship. With the right argument, clear evidence, and persistence, your work can speak for itself—no matter where you are.
If your NIW was denied or challenged, don’t lose hope. Each case is unique, and with the right legal approach, a strong argument can still be built.
If you have questions about the EB-2 NIW process or need help responding to a Request for Evidence, contact our team.
Do you have any immigration queastions? We’re here to help. You can book a 1h Consultation with one of our Attorneys here.